Comments on: Twilight Saga: New Moon, Top Critical Reviews

By: Christina

Christina — Sat, 19 Dec 2009 17:09:12 +0000

For these people that need to defend a movie or a book, its very immature everyone is entitled to there own opinion if it is good or bad. I think the movies are horrible bad acting ex. and the books drag on about the love Bella has for Edward …boring.

So overall you like the book , say it
If you don’t like me say it
But dont start calling people names because of there opinion
Just immature.

By: Celia

Celia — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 23:08:10 +0000

Look \"Diane\". Nobody likes a jerk and that\’s exactly whAT you are. And 1- Books have To go through proofreading and publishing and 5 out of 10 times they won\’t let you publish your book because its terrible (like you and your comments). They wouldn\’t let a bOOK like that be published. AND SHUTUP! Stop wasting your life bashing on things you don\’t like and just find something you DO like. Who cares if you don\’t like the series? WE DONT\’T! that\’s your opinion and everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but that doesn\’t mean you get the right to belittle things that people like. How would you feel if everyday your families, friends, teachers, boss, whatever bashesd about how ugly yourr clothes are and about how they hate the movies you like because the people in them are stupid idiots with butt ugly faces that no one should ever look upon without eye protection? YOU WOULDNT WANT TO HEAR IT. its your opinion that you like them and they should RESPECT your opinion not be a jerk about it. Just say I don\’t really like_____ and that\’s it. that\’s all anyone wants to hear. stop wasting your lives being jerks and find something you LIKE.

By: Diane Cantor

Diane Cantor — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 15:34:22 +0000

Look, I don’t want to bash anyone’s likes or dislikes. It’s just a terrible reflection on the state of the world. Cheesy soap opera meets vampires is one of the best selling movies of all time? The world is doomed. I went out and bought a gun and canned food, because these stupid books won’t save you from the collapse of civilization. The fact that all these morons love this movie just goes to show you how stupid people are. I’m going to write a series just like this and make hundreds of millions of dollars on people’s stupidity. Then when the franchise is done and all the movies have been made, I’m going to write a final epilogue. In it, I’m going to destroy the main character. He’s going to lose whatever crappy powers I made him have in the other books, he’s going to go broke both emotionally and financially, and he’s going to have to get a part time job as a greeter with Wal-Mart. Then just as he’s reached his low, he’s going to get arrested for male prostitution and attempted arson after he gets caught trying to burn down his Wal-Mart location while simultaneously giving a 65 year old married executive of a food supply company a hand job in the loading dock. Then, in the final chapter, I’m going to laugh and laugh and call out the entire fan base for being such suckers, and thank them for their millions of ill spent dollars. It will be glorious.

By: Baylee

Baylee — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 03:47:42 +0000

Ok well this is my opinion….. I loved the twilight books they were amazing I couldn’t stop reading them and I couldn’t believe it was just books! But when I saw the movies i felt ashamed to even call myself a Twilight fan. They were slow and the fight scene in Twilight was so boring and a waste of my time. If people like the people who made Harry Potter or the Lord of Rings ( like said above ) made it, it would be 100% better. Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson are great actors too so its not their fault the movies sucked big time. Now don’t bash me because this is my opinion!

Loving the books not so much the movies!

By: kassidy

kassidy — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 02:42:34 +0000

People who hate on it can hate all they want. For the critics, let me just clear this up for you: NOBODY ACTUALLY CARES WHAT YOU THINK! If you think your opinion actually makes a difference, you better pull your head out of your butt because you are sadly mistaken. Guess who the cast and crew wants to please? THE FANS! And…overall, the fans loved it. New Moon made over 140 million dollars opening weekend, and broke box office records. It’s really naive of people to think the movie was a fail when it made, and continue to makes, loads of money. The Twilight fans, aka the people whose opinions the cast and crew care about, liked it. So critics can get off their high horses and realize…they don’t speak for us, and we couldn’t care less about what they have to say.

By: wil

wil — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 17:27:52 +0000

I 100% agree with Dave. If they just made the movies a little more interesting this franchise could have been like Harry Potter and opened the doors for a whole new fan base. When I saw the original Twilight I was bored to tears because I’m not a moody teenage girl. It wouldn’t take much, a little more action and maybe a little humor or at least someone in the movie being happy for at least 30 seconds.

I’m pretty sure the fan base wouldn’t even care about a few little changes because they would be too busy screaming every time Pattinson came on the screen.

By: Nicki

Nicki — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 13:57:45 +0000

saw the movie friday with my husband who has never read the book are saw the first movie.he said that he had no idea what was goin on throught out the movie and i, as a true twilight fan, had to keep feeling him in. i think for amovie to be really good one should not have to read a book are watch the first of the series to be able to understand the plot. beacuse i knew the books well and the first movie i knew what was going on, but i could understand that if you had never had any knowledge of twilight how easy it was to get lost. i thought the movie was okay but it does not come close to touching the book. i know that, that is normally the case with movie and books because the books are always better, but when you watch harry potter and the lord of the rings movie they are really good movie and could be enjoyed even if you had no knowledge of the books. i also find kristen to be as irritating as she was in the fist movie and even though taylor was as good looking as rob ever thought of being he is not that great of an actor. i think that new moon the movie just like twilight will be a really big hit not because of the great acting, movie plot, and special effects but because the books are great, the fans are truely devoted fans, and because any little bit we can get for bella’s and edward’s world we will take it.

By: Dave

Dave — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 10:55:49 +0000

The movie needs to stop with all the cheesy stuff. Twilight if made into a not so teeny bopper movie could be a hit with everybody. I don’t like Twilight and I don’t mind that other people like it, but only if they would stop with all of the slow motion hair in the wind, I love you but we cant be (exit-slow motion vampire fly away), I think I could get into the saga. Hopefully the 3rd movie is dark,fast and tells a real story of a battle between vampires and shifters(werewolves).

By: Brittani

Brittani — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 04:40:56 +0000

i am a huge twilight fan and i was sooooo hype for this movie. I waited almost a damn year for New Moon and when i saw it it was nothing but dissapointment. The movie was too rushed but at the same time too slow. And oh my goodness that damn scene when kristen is sitting in front of the window for months pissed me off it was so uncreative. Jacob was the only reason to watch the movie he was bangn wordup. But Rob was really scary and ugly looking. The acting was very cheesy and the lines were wack. All the kissing scenes were not passionate they were more gross and akward than anything. Hopefully they get they shit together for the 3rd movie ** oh yeah and why did they put the proposal in this movie???? the director F*d up big time!!!

By: george

george — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 04:36:19 +0000

I have not read the books only seen the movies. I saw new moon last night and agree the acting was very poor. Kristen was expressionless which made her character boring and irritating. Story line wasnt too bad and I think it sets up for an intreging third movie.

By: Olivia

Olivia — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 22:04:46 +0000

I’ve been a big fan of the saga for over a year and didn’t like the first film. It was too much of an indie film, what with the blue film. The special affects were badly done and the acting was horrible. Yes, it’s something good to obsess over for awhile, but when the second film is horrid, too, that’s a bad sign.

The acting was horrible and the only thing that made it enjoyable were the parts of Jasper and Alice and Rosalie. The other actors were just horrible. Kristen’s voice is way to monotonous and she has no facial expressions at all. Rob, however, has talent, just not in the movies and that pisses me off especially. Truthfully, if anyone of them will grow out of the series, will be Nikki Reed and Rob Pattinson and Ashley Greene.

Nikki will direct and write more movies, seeing as she’s done an excellent job with Thirteen when she was a kid. And now that she has many movies in the production she’ll be writing and directing, she could make something of herself.

And Kristen, please just spare us and get out of the industry. Your horrible!

By: Isabel Mackinnon

Isabel Mackinnon — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 19:28:46 +0000

I was a twilight fan and have read all the books, however, overall the movie new moon disappointed me greatly. I felt there needed to be more passion during Bella amd Edward’s reunion and more joy experienced by Bella with the promise of Jacob’s undying devotion. In my opinion, RPattz made Edward a cold and callous jerk not at all endearing and sensitive- he sucked the love and intensity and infatuation for bella out of Stephenie’s character. Unfortunately, they also put too much make-up on him making him extremely unattractive. In terms of appearances I believe Jacob stole the show- and this coming from an Edward fan haha. I waited for a long time to see this movie, and although I wasn’t a completely obsessed fan to begin with I was indeed a loyal fan- now I’m not so sure. I think from this point on and its just a theory- that the audience dynamic has changed being composed more so of pre-teens and moms. Which sucks- this series is not a harry potter gimic its an outlet for emotional lovesick, soul wandering teenagers like my friends and who quite enjoy an alternative romantic date film to a plotless romantic comedy with zero originality and cheesy lines.

By: Rebecca

Rebecca — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 17:47:22 +0000

The whole twilight “thing” is such a waste of time. Vampires in love. Personally Stephanie Meyers is not a very good writer she drags on everything that involves Bella and her feelings and with RobertP … clearly unattractive the only good thing he has is his eyes… Also the movies are retarded…Everything that they do is so motionless, like the acting is bad. God bless anyone who likes it its cool whatever be obsessed, I personally I think its a waste… And for the turds that are going to reply saying that if its a waste why am I saying anything or try to make some humourous comeback …Dont… may opinion and overall I think twilight is a cult and quite stupid.